The response from almost all legal experts is simple: there are no provisions in the WTO agreements allowing expulsion or suspension
By Peter Ungphakorn
POSTED MARCH 23, 2022 | UPDATED MARCH 26, 2022
Can a member of the World Trade Organization (WTO) be expelled? The short answer is no. There is no legal means of doing that.
The question arises because of a number of calls to expel Russia, to suspend its membership or to suspend its ability to act in the WTO, in response to its invasion of Ukraine.
Those three are not exactly the same. The first two — expulsion or suspending membership — are clearly legal issues. They require decisions by the WTO’s membership.
The response from almost all experts in WTO trade law is simple: there are no provisions in the WTO agreements that would allow expulsion or suspension.
Continue reading “Can a WTO member be expelled? No. But …”
Kicking Russia out of the World Trade Organization is probably impossible, but other actions are available
Painting (detail) by Chris Edmund © used with permission
List of measures announced or proposed
that come under the WTO system, periodically updated
Can a WTO member be expelled? No. But …
By Peter Ungphakorn
POSTED FEBRUARY 28, 2022 | UPDATED MARCH 4, 2022
Two senior US politicians announced on February 25, 2022 that they were introducing legislation to suspend World Trade Organization terms in US trade with Russia and to seek expelling Russia from the WTO.
Lloyd Doggett, chair of the House of Representatives Ways and Means subcommittee on health, and Earl Blumenauer, his counterpart on the subcommittee on trade, proposed the bill following Russia’s “unprovoked invasion of Ukraine”.
Since then, at least three similar bills have been proposed in the US Senate.
Meanwhile, Ukraine and Canada have actually implemented action against Russia within in the WTO system, and the EU has said it is considering its own action.
The Doggett and Blumenauer bill would make it easier for the US to impose trade sanctions against imports of Russian goods, in addition to the commercial, financial and personal sanctions the US and its allies have already initiated. That includes new EU sanctions in trade with Belarus (not a WTO member).
The bill would also “seek the suspension of the Russian Federation’s membership in the WTO”, a more difficult prospect.
Continue reading “US politicians call for trade action against Russia in the WTO”