Fisheries subsidies – Trade β Blog

Scoring the Ministerial Conference results in the WTO director-general’s ‘half-full’ glass

Is it right to judge the Abu Dhabi Ministerial Conference by counting the decisions as if they each had equal significance? This is how we’d score the 10 that were agreed and some others that weren’t

By Peter Ungphakorn and Robert Wolfe
POSTED APRIL 5, 2024 | UPDATED APRIL 23, 2024

Judging by the WTO website’s coverage, the World Trade Organization’s Abu Dhabi Ministerial Conference was a success, albeit a qualified one, at least in WTO Director-General Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala’s assessments. Is this credible?

“Despite the more than challenging context, we concluded [the Ministerial Conference] with 10 consensus multilateral ministerial decisions and declarations,” she told ambassadors to the WTO on March 21. “That’s why I personally see the glass as half full.”

We, however, conclude that the glass is quite a lot less than half full.

Despite the more than challenging context, we concluded … with 10 consensus multilateral ministerial decisions and declarations. That’s why I personally see the glass as half full
— Ngozi Okonjo-Iweala

We looked closely at what was agreed in Abu Dhabi and what wasn’t, and we scored each issue. The results are below, a bit like the scorecards we produced after the last Ministerial Conference in Geneva in 2022, but slightly different.

And we believe over-selling the result may be unhelpful because it may encourage complacency. Members can and should do better. And they should start working on that now.

What next? Seven talking points after the WTO’s 2024 Ministerial Conference

Lots to think about as WTO delegations pick up the pieces from Abu Dhabi and look ahead to the next conference in two years’ time and beyond

By Peter Ungphakorn and Robert Wolfe
POSTED MARCH 13, 2024 | UPDATED MARCH 20, 2024

We’ve deliberately taken our time. The World Trade Organization’s 2024 Ministerial Conference in Abu Dhabi ended almost two weeks ago, after deadlock forced it to be extended by over a day, into the early hours of March 2.

Before the conference we had warned against expecting too much. We had argued that what was going to be essential was to preserve the system. Most issues were not ripe, and the geopolitical situation meant political energy was elsewhere.

Not to cause any harm seemed to be enough to say “job done”.

Some have criticised us for being too complacent, for being satisfied with the status quo. Far from it. We were simply recognising reality.

Quite a lot has been written and said about the conference, its minor successes and the major failures to meet expectations. Here are some talking points that stand out for us. It’s time to look ahead.

Definitely. Maybe. Unlikely. Who knows? Issues on the WTO conference agenda

We’d better be prepared for little or nothing substantial when ministers meet in Abu Dhabi at the end of the month

By Peter Ungphakorn and Robert Wolfe
POSTED FEBRUARY 21, 2024 | UPDATED FEBRUARY 27, 2024

Two large but stubborn members may prevent ministers from agreeing on anything important at the World Trade Organization’s upcoming Ministerial Conference, and so the cynics are circling with doom-laden prophecies that “the WTO” is likely to fail again.

One is India, which is demanding the impossible in agriculture and threatening to block several other issues supported by a majority of WTO members. The other is the US, which is also — but more quietly — defying a majority of members on appeals in WTO dispute settlement.

Between them, they could ensure that the February 26–29 meeting in Abu Dhabi becomes yet another where WTO trade ministers kick dozens of cans down the road.

Cynics circle as another WTO Ministerial Conference heads for small pickings

Given the challenging circumstances, system preservation may be the most important outcome

By Peter Ungphakorn and Robert Wolfe
POSTED FEBRUARY 21, 2024 | UPDATED FEBRUARY 27, 2024

The cynics are circling the World Trade Organization’s upcoming Ministerial Conference with doom-laden prophecies that the “WTO” is likely to fail, again.

The cans that were kicked down the road in Geneva in 2022 are now supposed to produce content in Abu Dhabi in 2024. The prospects of that are sobering.

But the WTO is not just its Ministerial Conferences, and the purpose of these conferences is not merely concluding new agreements. Given the challenging circumstances, system preservation may be the most important outcome.

Fisheries subsidies draft published for WTO Ministerial Conference

But with many issues unresolved, the chair says officials will continue to work on it before and during the Abu Dhabi conference

UPDATE: On April 12, 2024, chair Einar Gunnarsson circulated a copy of an “advance draft” as emailed to ministers in the early hours of March 1, 2024, close to the end of the Abu Dhabi Ministerial Conference. His accompanying explanation includes a detailed account of what happened at the conference.

Paragraphs 56 to 59 of the chair’s explanation describe further convergence after that draft was circulated, although some issues remained unsettled. It was the further revisions that Fiji and Vanuatu wanted discussed in the final plenary sessions at the conference, sparking a furious outburst of objections from India’s Commerce Minister Piyush Goyal. As Gunnarsson says, work will continue.

By Peter Ungphakorn
POSTED FEBRUARY 19, 2024 | UPDATED APRIL 13, 2024

The fisheries subsidies draft for the World Trade Organization’s February 26–29, 2024 Ministerial Conference in Abu Dhabi was published on February 16 along with a detailed explanation by the chair, Ambassador Einar Gunnarsson of Iceland.

“All members are very aware that next week, the eyes of the world will be on us,” Gunnarsson told journalists on February 19. (His full statement is here.)

“I believe that we have every possibility to deliver a meaningful outcome and bring these very long-running fisheries subsidies negotiations to a close at last. I will do everything in my power to help that chance become a reality.”

Achieving that is not guaranteed, and work continues in the final days before the conference to resolve at least some of the remaining differences.

(The draft and the explanation are presented side by side here.)

What the fisheries subsidies talks’ chair reported to WTO ambassadors

Iceland ambassador Einar Gunnarsson’s report to the final General Council meeting before the 2024 Ministerial Conference, after a busy ‘Fish Month’

SEE ALSO
Updates on the fisheries subsidies talks. And all stories tagged “fisheries subsidies”

By Peter Ungphakorn
POSTED FEBRUARY 16, 2024 | UPDATED FEBRUARY 16, 2024

Iceland’s ambassador Einar Gunnarsson, who chairs the World Trade Organization’s fisheries subsidies negotiations is expected to circulate on Monday (February 19, 2024) a new draft on curbing subsidies that contribute to overcapacity and overfishing.

The draft will be the final version for the February 26–29 Ministerial Conference in Abu Dhabi (“MC13”). At the previous conference in Geneva, June 2022, WTO ministers set the Abu Dhabi conference as the deadline for concluding the negotiations.

The draft is nicknamed “Fish 2” because it covers provisions that could not be agreed and were therefore dropped from the 2022 Fisheries Subsidies Agreement (“Fish 1”).

The new draft will draw on a “Fish Month” of negotiations that began in mid-January. This is Gunnarsson’s report to WTO ambassadors on the talks and on his intentions for the final draft, delivered on February 14, at the final General Council meeting before the Ministerial Conference.

Barbados’ unusual contribution to the WTO fisheries subsidies negotiations

The main point of its “room document” is a video on the Barbadian matriarchy of fishing

SEE ALSO
Updates on the negotiations
and all stories tagged “fisheries subsidies”

By Peter Ungphakorn
POSTED FEBRUARY 12, 2024 | UPDATED FEBRUARY 12, 2024

A contribution from Barbados to the World Trade Organization’s negotiations on fisheries subsidies has a title and content that are both unusual: “The Barbadian matriarchy of fishing” featuring a YouTube video.

“This video will show all WTO members why fisheries matters for Barbadian livelihoods, food security, and women’s economic empowerment — and why the special and differential treatment we are asking for also matters,” Barbados ambassador Matthew Wilson told fellow-delegates.

“It will help you understand why Barbados takes the positions we do in this room and what we mean when we say small scale and artisanal. You will see why we say unduly restricting our fisheries sector potential is counterproductive and that we need to address unsustainable practices by distant water fishers that have risked the health of our yields.”

Chair upbeat about members’ approach to final WTO fish subsidies push

Negotiators’ ‘constructive tone and well-organized and business-like participation in the meeting left me with an increased sense of optimism’, said Einar Gunnarsson

By Peter Ungphakorn
POSTED JANUARY 16, 2024 | UPDATED JANUARY 16, 2024

The start of the final “fish month” before the Word Trade Organization’s Ministerial Conference in Abu Dhabi has been promising, Einar Gunnarsson, Iceland’s ambassador who chairs the WTO talks, said today (January 16, 2024).

“Overall, the positive tone and constructive spirit with which members engaged demonstrated their continued commitment to conclude the second wave of negotiations by [the Ministerial Conference],” he said. (His full statement is below, the WTO website news story is here.)

Gunnarsson was speaking to journalists after opening the four weeks of talks the previous day.

The aim is to have a clean, agreed text by February 9. This would be sent, via the February 14 General Council meeting to the February 26–29 Ministerial Conference.

Chair issues new draft before final fisheries subsidies month

Agreement by February 29 depends on four weeks of intensive talks. Can members settle their many differences?

See also:
Updates, timeline and links | all articles tagged “fisheries subsidies”
Technical note on subsidies for fisheries

By Peter Ungphakorn
POSTED JANUARY 2, 2024 | UPDATED JANUARY 13, 2024

A new draft and explanatory note on the Fisheries Subsidies Agreement’s “missing piece” was circulated to members on December 21, 2023, the World Trade Organization’s final working day of the year.

The chair, Ambassador Einar Gunnarsson of Iceland, has given WTO members four weeks from January 15 to February 9, 2024 to try to agree on a final version, which they would submit to the February 26–29 Ministerial Conference in Abu Dhabi.

SUMMARY

Too long, don’t want to read? If you just want the essence, stick with this SUMMARY section, which is about 15 short paragraphs. Continue beyond that if you want the DETAILS. Right at the end are the full texts. This article is long because a lot remains to be sorted out. The chair’s explanation is a seven-page document.

UPCOMING KEY FISH DATES
Over the New Year — Some consultations possible, but generally a break
January 15–February 9 — “fish month” of intensive talks
February 14 — final General Council meeting before the Ministerial Conference
February 15–25 — delegations’ preparations: coordinating with capitals and ministers, travelling to Abu Dhabi
February 26–29 — Ministerial Conference

For the first time since he floated a trial text in September, Gunnarsson released this version publicly.

The chair’s draft and his accompanying explanation are reproduced side by side below. An explanation of the details is also below. (The original pdf format of the draft is here and the accompanying explanation is here).

The chair’s detailed explanation shows that differences still have to be bridged throughout the text, although it remains to be seen where countries’ real red lines are, and whether they can compromise at the last minute. In 2022 they still couldn’t, 21 years after the talks were launched.

Six talking points from the year’s final General Council meeting

From negotiations to WTO reform, the Ministerial Conference is unlikely to deliver much. Time to hand out some Mario Balotelli shirts?

By Peter Ungphakorn
POSTED DECEMBER 21, 2023 | UPDATED JANUARY 24, 2024

The World Trade Organization’s General Council had 25 items on the agenda for its last meeting of 2023, several of them with multiple sub-items. Most are — frankly — boring although essential for the record of WTO operations.

But some points were worth discussing from the meeting, which we can extend to include year-end sessions of the Trade Negotiations Committee and Dispute Settlement Body.

Here are six. They won’t hit the headlines, except perhaps one, but they do tell us something about the state of play on bigger issues, and where the WTO might be heading, particularly with the February 26–29 Abu Dhabi Ministerial Conference now only two months away.